Refinancing Your Mortgage? Maximize the Tax Breaks
Diane Kennedy, CPA
TaxLoopholes, LLC

nterest rates may be falling slowly, but they are
falling, as the Federal Reserve seeks to ease credit. As of this
writing, the average rate on a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage is below
6%, according to Freddie Mac.
As recently as July 2007, the average rate was 6.7%. Therefore,
you might want to refinance your mortgage to save on interest
expenses.
Payoff for good
behavior: Today,
lenders are penalizing borrowers with subpar credit scores by
making them pay higher interest rates. Conversely, borrowers
with good scores pay lower rates.
Example: According to Fair Isaac,
developer of the FICO credit score used by most lenders, someone
with a 680 credit score might pay 6.063% for a 30-year loan. With a
720 score (around the national median), you would likely pay 5.8%,
and 5.6% with a superior 760 score.
You can purchase your credit score at myFICO.com (www.myfico.com).
Bottom line: If your credit score has
improved since you took out your mortgage, perhaps because late
mortgage or late credit card payments from prior years no longer
count in your score, you might be able to trim your costs by
refinancing now.
tax tactics
If you’re refinancing your mortgage, knowing the tax rules can
help you make the most of available tax deductions.
Strategy: To be sure that all of your
interest will be deductible, refinance with a dollar-for-dollar
replacement loan.
Example: Your current loan balance is
$200,000 on a 6.7% loan. If you refinance with a $200,000, 5.7%
loan, all of the interest will be tax deductible as long as the
total of your home loans is $1 million or less.
Cashing out: Even after the recent slump in
home prices, many houses are still worth far more than the
outstanding balances on their mortgages. In such cases, home owners
often refinance for larger amounts, pulling out cash.
Example: Your home is appraised at $300,000, and your current
loan balance is $200,000. You find a lender willing to provide you
with an 80% loan-to-value mortgage, so you borrow $240,000.
Thus, you pay off the old $200,000 loan and pocket $40,000.
Strategy: The best time to get a cash-out mortgage is when
you’re planning an addition to your home, or if you plan a
substantial renovation. If you spend the cash from the home loan in
this manner, all the interest on the refinanced loan will be
deductible.
If you don’t use any or all of the cash for home improvement,
the excess will be considered home-equity debt.
Example: You refinance a $200,000 loan
with a $240,000 loan, as above, and spend $20,000 putting in a new
bathroom. You use the other $20,000 to buy a car.
Result: Of your new loan, $220,000 is
considered "home-acquisition debt," so interest on this amount is
deductible. The other $20,000 is considered "home-equity debt,"
which falls under different rules.
How it works: The interest on home-equity
debt of $100,000 or less is deductible no matter how it’s spent. If
you use the $20,000 from your cash-out mortgage to buy a car, the
interest on that $20,000 probably will be fully deductible (as long
you don’t owe more than $80,000 on a home-equity loan or line of
credit, which would push you over the $100,000 deductibility
threshold).
Trap: For home-equity debt to be
fully deductible, the total mortgage debt on the house cannot
exceed its value.
In the above example, where the home is appraised at $300,000
and home-acquisition debt after refinancing is $220,000, interest
on only $80,000 of home-equity debt will be deductible.
Caution: Be especially careful about
using cash-out mortgage money for expenses other than home
improvements if you must pay the alternative minimum tax (AMT).
Why: If you are subject to the AMT,
home-equity debt is subject to the same $100,000 limit for
deducting the interest. However, the deduction is
available only
if the money is used for home improvement.
If you are subject to the AMT and use home-equity debt to pay
off consumer debt, buy a boat, etc., you can’t take a deduction for
the interest.
ahead on points
When you refinance a mortgage, you may pay "points" up
front.
Example: You refinance a $200,000 loan
and pay two points (2%), or $4,000. Paying points will reduce the
interest on a loan, so it may be worthwhile if you’ll be in the
house for at least several years.
Tax treatment: When a mortgage is refinanced,
points you pay can be deducted over the life of the loan.
Example: You pay $4,000 in points for a
30-year (360-month) loan. Every month that this loan is
outstanding, you can deduct $11.
Payoff: If the loan is paid off early,
all of the not-yet-deducted points can be deducted at once. This
might be the case when the house is sold or when the refinanced
loan is refinanced once more.
In the case of a re-refinance, the old points can be deducted
immediately and you can begin a monthly schedule for deducting
points on the new loan.
Exception: If you refinance with the same
lender, you can’t deduct the old points. Instead, those points are
folded into the new point-deduction schedule.
Example: You have $3,000 worth of
nondeducted points when you refinance with the same lender and pay
$4,000 in points on the new loan.
Now you have $7,000 in points to deduct. On a 30-year loan, you
would deduct $19 ($7,000 divided by 360) each month.
Loophole: If you use a cash-out mortgage
and use some of the proceeds to improve your principal residence, a
corresponding portion of the points can be deducted up front.
Example: You refinance a loan secured
by your principal residence, borrowing $240,000 and paying $4,800
in points. Of the $240,000 that you borrow, $40,000 (one-sixth) is
used for home improvements.
Result: You can deduct $800 (one-sixth
of $4,800) immediately. The other $4,000 paid for points can be
written off over 360 months (30 years).
However, if the refinancing and home improvements were done on a
second home, the entire $4,800 would have to be written off over
the life of the loan.
In all cases, you take deductions for points paid on Schedule A
of your tax return -- as an interest expense -- so the tax break is
available only if you itemize deductions.