Foods That Seem Healthy... But Really Are Not -
How food
manufacturers and marketers trick us into thinking foods are good
for us when they’re not
David Grotto, RD
Nutrition Housecall, LLC

early everyone wants to eat healthier. The food
industry, which keeps a close eye on America’s changing tastes, has
introduced thousands of foods that purport to be healthy -- but are
they really?
Too many people assume that anything that
comes from a health-food store is good for you or that quantities
don’t matter when you’re eating a “good” food.
Personal
story: One of my first clients was a
strict vegetarian, but this woman was 5'2" and weighed 250 pounds.
Something was clearly amiss. She told me that she used nearly a
pint of olive oil in recipes because it’s a “healthy” fat.
Some foods, such as vegetables, whole
grains, legumes, etc., are almost always good for you. But many of
the foods that are promoted with healthy-sounding terms, such as
“natural” or “vitamin-packed,” actually are loaded with sugar
and/or fat and are unacceptably high in calories.
Common offenders -- and healthier
alternatives...
SMOOTHIES
Some smoothies can have more calories than
sodas, making them an unhealthy choice to have regularly. My
daughter once bought a peanut butter smoothie. I did the
calculations and found that it had about 1,000 calories.
Healthier: Make your own smoothie using
just fresh fruit and adding skim milk if you want. Or mix four
ounces of fruit juice with four ounces of sparkling water. It
tastes delicious, is relatively low in calories and has the same
nutrients as a serving of whole fruit (though less fiber).
PROTEIN BARS
Millions of Americans replace one or more
meals daily with bars -- granola bars, high-protein bars,
meal-replacement bars, etc. Many of these are high in sugar and/or
fat and deliver 300 calories or more. It’s fine to occasionally use
one of these bars as a meal replacement, but they’re too high in
calories to have in addition to meals.
Healthier: Make up your own healthy
snacks, using a mixture of nuts, seeds and dried fruit. One-half
ounce of almonds (about 12) and one tablespoon of dried fruit
totals about 140 calories. When you do crave a bar, have one that
has at least three grams of fiber, with no more than 150 calories.
Try Luna small-size organic bars.
FROZEN YOGURT
Healthier than ice cream? Not necessarily.
Yogurt is one of the healthiest foods you can eat, but most frozen
brands have more in common with desserts than with health
foods. Check
the label: Some frozen yogurts have the
same number of calories as ice cream. They may even have similar
amounts of sugar and fat. Also, it’s rare to find live and active
cultures -- the probiotic organisms that make natural yogurt so
healthy -- in frozen products.
Healthier: One of the newer versions of
frozen yogurt. For example, Berry Chill, a yogurt chain based in
Chicago, is producing products that are relatively low in fat and
sugar and contain live and active cultures. Other manufacturers are
following suit, such as New England–based Brigham’s with its
premium frozen yogurt, élan. Look for the LAC seal on frozen yogurt
containers -- it means that the product has at least 10 million
live and active cultures.
PRETZELS
They’re often touted as a healthier
alternative to potato chips because they have less fat. A one-ounce
pretzel serving usually has about one gram of fat, compared to up
to 10 grams in a one-ounce serving of some potato chips. However,
most pretzels are high in salt. They also have a high glycemic
index because they consist mostly of refined wheat flour and
cornstarch -- they’re quickly transformed to sugar during
digestion, which can increase blood glucose levels and lead to
weight gain.
Be wary of pretzels with added wheat or oat
bran -- these often are just “window dressing” and not a
significant source of whole grains.
Healthier: Satisfy your “crunch craving”
with a mix of nuts, seeds and dried fruit.
FAKE WHOLE-WHEAT BREAD
Real whole-wheat bread is among the
healthiest foods you can eat. Some brands, however, only look like
whole wheat -- manufacturers often add a brown color to make them
look more wholesome. Another
trick: Manufacturers super-size the
slices so that they can make higher fiber claims on the label.
Healthier: A bread with normal-size
slices that contains at least three grams of fiber per serving.
Read the ingredient label. The word “whole” -- whole wheat, whole
grain, etc. -- should be first in the list.
MUFFINS
Today’s big muffins often seem like they’re
loaded with nutritious ingredients, such as fruit or bran, but many
muffins that are sold in supermarkets or coffee shops, such as
Starbucks, are loaded with fat and sugar and range from 400 to 500
calories each.
Healthier: A small one-and-a-half ounce
muffin that’s made with bran or a whole grain. A muffin this size
that’s not loaded with sugar and/or fat usually contains about 100
calories.
RICE MIXES
Brown rice has more fiber and
disease-fighting phytochemicals than white rice, but people don’t
always want to take the time to cook brown rice. Instead, they buy
a packaged rice pilaf, both for convenience and extra flavor. Most
of these products are very high in sodium, as well as fat.
Healthier: Uncle Ben’s microwavable brown
rice. It’s ready in just a few minutes, and you can season it to
your own taste -- without adding salt or oil.