Isn't It Their
Turn to Pick Up the Check?
Jeanne Fleming, PhD
Leonard Schwarz

oney conflicts among friends and family often
come up when dining out. How to handle these awkward situations...
PROBLEM: Friends choose high-end restaurants for
get-togethers, forcing you to split exorbitant tabs
that you are not comfortable paying.
What to do: The first time this
problem occurs, pay your share even if the bill is much more than
you expected. After all, when you agreed to go out to dinner, you
tacitly agreed to pay your share. But before the next meal,
politely explain that you prefer to spend, say, $60 per couple when
you eat out, not $150. If less expensive meals do not interest your
friends, find things to do together that don’t cost as much, such
as going for a hike or to a movie.
PROBLEM: Your friends
like to order fine wine, doubling the cost of eating
out with them.
What to do: It is perfectly
reasonable to tell your friends that expensive wine is not in your
budget. If these friends insist on pricey wine with dinner, tell
them that you will supply a home-cooked meal at your place and they
can supply the 1970 Mouton Rothschild.
PROBLEM: Wealthy
friends or relatives offer to pay more than their
share.You wonder if letting a well-heeled friend or
relative pick up the tab when you eat out or pay your way on a
joint vacation will damage the relationship.
What to do: There is nothing
wrong with accepting the occasional lavish gift from a well-off
friend or relative. Accept the gift graciously, but be certain to
reciprocate. The reciprocation needn’t be comparably expensive, and
may even be in the form of a service -- babysitting, say, or
helping with a computer.
Only if you allow the other person to systematically pick up the
tab is there a problem.
PROBLEM: Some members
of a group order expensive meals but want to divide the check
evenly. According to a survey we conducted, one-third
of the public believes that when friends go out to dinner, someone
always is unhappy with the way the check is divided.
What to do: If a friend or
relative does not offer to pay his/her fair share, don’t just grin
and bear it. Take a moment to look over the check, do the math, and
propose an equitable distribution.
Example of what to say: “Let’s
see. It looks like your share is $75 and ours is $50. Does that
sound right?”
If events get away from you and the bill has already been split
by someone else in an unfair way, it’s reasonable for you to
propose splitting it more fairly. This might seem pushy, but you
have nothing to be embarrassed about -- the other person does.
Example: Six members of your
group order $12 pasta dishes, while the other two choose $22
steaks. The meat eaters should at least offer to pay extra. If they
fail to do so, say in a friendly tone, “OK, you carnivores. You owe
an extra 10 bucks to cover those steaks.”
PROBLEM: You picked up
the check the last time. Now you’re out with the same
couple, the bill has arrived, and they’re not reaching for it.
What to do: Don’t be a pushover.
Push the check their way, smile warmly and in a completely
nonjudgmental and nonaccusatory tone say, “I think this one’s
yours.”